
HiMCM and MidMCM Student Tips for Your First Competition
We recently asked three students to tell us about their first COMAP modeling contests. Harrison admitted his team wasn’t organized. Soha hadn’t expected to spend so much time hunting for reliable data. Zoeb remembered texting his teammates in a panic.
If you’re after HiMCM and MidMCM student tips, they’ve got some. Here’s what Harrison, Soha, and Zoeb shared about taking part in the High School Mathematical Contest in Modeling (HiMCM®) and Middle Mathematical Contest in Modeling (MidMCM).
Meet the Student Panelists
- Harrison is a senior at Nueva School with three HiMCM contests behind him. A school email caught his interest as a freshman, and he went on to take his advisor’s math modeling class the next year.
- Soha, a sophomore at Orlando Science High School in Florida, participated in MidMCM twice before completing her first HiMCM last year. She was introduced to modeling through the Orlando Math Circle, where she also volunteers.
- Zoeb attends Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology in Northern Virginia. His math teacher encouraged him to join the school’s modeling club. He’s since competed in HiMCM twice and now teaches other club members how to build models and write their papers.
HiMCM Director Dr. Kristin Fetherston-Arney asked the questions. Harrison, Soha, and Zoeb shared what they remembered, including the parts that didn’t go so well.
Watch the Q&A below, or read on for their tips.
Viewing from China? The student Q&A is also available on Bilibili.
You Don’t Need to Know All the Math Before You Begin
Soha encouraged students to give the contest a try, even if they haven’t taken higher-level math classes yet. “You don’t need to know, like, advanced math,” she said.
Soha spent a lot of her first HiMCM researching and writing. If you like that kind of work, there’s a place for you on a team, even if you’re new to mathematical modeling. She also encouraged students to give themselves room to learn. “Making mistakes is part of what you have to do,” she said.
Break the Modeling Problem into Smaller Parts
Zoeb remembers feeling panicked when he read his first HiMCM problem as a freshman. He immediately contacted his teammates to arrange a meeting. He felt better once his team sat down and started working. They broke the problem into smaller pieces, figuring out what they could simplify and what they needed to keep.
Harrison’s first team was three freshmen trying to figure out how dandelions would spread across a field. They worked on some parts as a group, but weren’t sure how to divide up the problem. Getting everyone together was hard, too.
After a few contests, he found that they didn’t all need to work on the same thing. One or two people could take on a piece of the model. He liked working in pairs because there was someone right there to bounce ideas off.
Expect to Research Things You’ve Never Considered
Soha follows sports, so she was happy to get a HiMCM problem about major sporting events. There were plenty of opinions about football online, but her team needed information they could actually use. She also found herself thinking about things she’d never considered while watching a game, like the emissions from teams traveling to play.
Zoeb’s team ran into a different challenge with a problem about the environmental impact of computing. The question already included a lot of factors, and they spent much of their time figuring out what else to consider. He was still looking into it weeks after they’d submitted their paper because he wanted to know more.
For both students, the research became part of what made the math modeling competition worthwhile.
Choose Teammates You Can Communicate With
When asked what he would look for in a teammate, Harrison focused on someone he knew well and had worked with before. “In fact, I feel like communication oftentimes is like the make or break for a team to be able to work well together,” he said.
Soha hadn’t known her teammates before they signed up. They went to different schools in different cities, so all their work happened online. Finding a few hours when everyone could meet was hard. Next time, she’d look for people she knows and can meet with in person.
Prepare for HiMCM and MidMCM with Practice and Past Papers
Harrison said his first team wasn’t all that committed. They had homework and sports, and didn’t get together very often. Looking back, he thinks they needed to give the contest more time. That’s his advice to new teams, too: make time to prepare for the contest, and make sure everyone is ready to put in the work.
Harrison also found it helpful to read past HiMCM solutions. He could compare his team’s paper with others written about the same problem and see how differently they approached it.
Zoeb suggested watching 3Blue1Brown on YouTube to learn more about the math and how to break down problems. His club also has students read papers on arXiv to see how researchers organize their papers and explain their ideas.
Mathematical Modeling Can Lead to New Interests
Zoeb said writing contest papers taught him to be more patient with his own research. He also got better at organizing his ideas and putting them into writing.
Harrison saw the connection during a summer internship, where he worked with a model of how ultrasound interacts with a human head. His contest experience helped him understand what they were trying to predict and how the model worked.
For Soha, modeling helped her imagine a future studying applied mathematics and working in basketball analytics. Her interest in using mathematical modeling to understand basketball includes analyzing player statistics and informing decisions about trades and game strategy.
Harrison came back after a rough first contest. Zoeb kept researching his problem after it was over. Soha started thinking about a career in basketball analytics. They each got something different out of giving it a try.
As Harrison put it, mathematical modeling is “literally everywhere.”
Written by
COMAP
The Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications is an award-winning non-profit organization whose mission is to improve mathematics education for students of all ages. Since 1980, COMAP has worked with teachers, students, and business people to create learning environments where mathematics is used to investigate and model real issues in our world.
